ORCID

https://orcid.org/0009-0000-5180-1025

Document Type

Dataset

DOI

https://doi.org/10.21974/fzpg-z197

Publication Date

2026

Keywords

Animation, Real-time engines, Unreal Engine, Paradigm shift, Vendor discourse, Content analysis

Abstract

Scholarship often follows industry in describing real-time game engines such as Unreal Engine as a paradigm shift in audiovisual production. The article tests that claim for animation. A critical review of 18 peer-reviewed publications (2019–2026) rates four criteria derived from Thomas Kuhn (anomaly, crisis, new rules of practice and incommensurability) with an explicit rule that counts only independent full-text evidence. A qualitative content analysis then codes twelve animation case studies published by the engine’s vendor, Epic Games, for rupture vocabulary, the vendor’s role and the conditions of production, and traces vendor material in the academic literature. No criterion is fully met: the evidence shows working rules changing within an unchanged standard of quality, on a thin and partly vendor-mediated base.

Description

This data supports the manuscript, Real-Time Engines and Animation: Testing the Paradigm Shift Claim and the Vendor’s Narrative by Ernesto Rodriguez Cruz, submitted to Revista Mediterránea de Comunicación (Mediterranean Journal of Communication). Article currently under review.

The dataset contains the coding behind a critical review that tests the claim that real-time game engines constitute a paradigm shift in animation production. It includes the corpus of 21 academic sources, the eight decision rules, the academic statements coded against four Kuhn-derived criteria with page references, the analysis of twelve Epic Games animation case studies with URLs and archived copies, and the population of vendor texts from which they were drawn. Every row was checked against its source three times. All sources are publicly available.

Description of the files: one Excel workbook (.xlsx) with eight sheets, also available as tab-separated text files:

  • README / codebook: description of every sheet, column and value, decision rules, page conventions and method note.
  • corpus: the academic publications assessed, with scope, publication type and inclusion status, plus the vendor’s field guides.
  • rules: the decision rules applied in the coding.
  • academic_statements: statements extracted from the academic sources, with page, criterion, direction, scope, basis and whether each counts for a rating.
  • vendor_lexicon_matches: every match of the rupture vocabulary in the twelve vendor texts, with the decision to keep or discard it.
  • vendor_role_conditions: the vendor’s role, the conditions of production and the difficulties reported in each text.
  • vendor_material_tracing: academic statements traced back to vendor material.
  • vendor_cases: the twelve vendor texts, with date, URL and archived copy.

File Format

.tsv, .txt, .xlsx

Language

English

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Share

COinS